CO129-275 - Governor Sir Robinson - 1897 [1-5] — Page 505

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

and to this the Governor is willing to accede

of alleged murder, manslaughter,

in

cases

of piracy, burglary, housebreaking and

robbery

with violence, where the Accused has not

been more than

6 months in Hong Kong

& where the depositions are taken before the British Consul who will certify that no compulsion appears to have been

used it"

you will see that Section III of the draft Ordinance of 1889 contained a

provision

to the effect that depositions in China

[GR3114/29]

should be taken as evidence [see on 314 pg] that this was approved of by Lord Knutsford in his Despatch para: 5 on 3114. The clause however met with the strongest opposition from the Unofficial Members

of Council

and

was omitted [see

newspaper Reports & also Sir

W. des Vaux's Despatch

GR176/11.7]

I consider that the proposed safeguard

though not entirely satisfactory

is

sufficiently

warrant their being approved: we

do not want to protect

notorious criminals from

justice,

even Chinese justice; in fact I should

be inclined to go further than the Governor

to add

the following crimes taken from

the

Schedule of the 1889

Ordinance to the list of those in

which depositions taken in China be accepted i.e. Malicious Wounding,

Rape, Abduction, Child Stealing, Kidnapping

Arson & Sinking or Destroying

a

Vessel at

Sea;

I should be disposed to include all

crimes of violence and all that I have

mentioned may be included under

fraud.

Copy of the Governor's Despatch with Sazla in pipe torber routed and say.

Edit History

2026-05-28 18:38:25 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
and to this the Governor is willing to accede of alleged murder, manslaughter, in cases of piracy, burglary, housebreaking and robbery with violence, where the Accused has not been more than 6 months in Hong Kong & where the depositions are taken before the British Consul who will certify that no compulsion appears to have been used it" you will see that Section III of the draft Ordinance of 1889 contained a provision to the effect that depositions in China [GR3114/29] should be taken as evidence [see on 314 pg] that this was approved of by Lord Knutsford in his Despatch para: 5 on 3114. The clause however met with the strongest opposition from the Unofficial Members of Council and was omitted [see newspaper Reports & also Sir W. des Vaux's Despatch GR176/11.7] I consider that the proposed safeguard though not entirely satisfactory is sufficiently warrant their being approved: we do not want to protect notorious criminals from justice, even Chinese justice; in fact I should be inclined to go further than the Governor to add the following crimes taken from the Schedule of the 1889 Ordinance to the list of those in which depositions taken in China be accepted i.e. Malicious Wounding, Rape, Abduction, Child Stealing, Kidnapping Arson & Sinking or Destroying a Vessel at Sea; I should be disposed to include all crimes of violence and all that I have mentioned may be included under fraud. Copy of the Governor's Despatch with Sazla in pipe torber routed and say.
Baseline (Original)
and to this the your is willing to accede of alleged murder, manslaughter, in cases pirncy burglary housebreaking and rended robbery with violence, where the Accused has not more than 6 months in Hong Kong & where the depositions are taken before the British Consul who will certify that no compulsion appears to have been uned it" you will see that Section III of the draft Ordinance of 1889 contained a provision to the effect that depositions in China 3114/29] should be taken as evidence [see on 314 pg] that this was approved of by Lord Knutsford in his Despatch parag: 5 ou 3114. The clause however met with the stingest the Unofficial hembers opposition from of Council les, et see anuited was omitted [see newspaper Reports & also Sir Vaux's Desfalch G des on 17611.7 I consider that the prevent proposed safeguardi though not entirely saliifactory so b au 497 sufficiently warrant their being approved: we not want to protect justice, do 1 to protect notorious criminals from even Chinese justice; in fact I should be inclined to go further than the gour to add the following crimes taken from 1989 the Schedule of the Ordinance to the list of there; auay to which deponitions taken in China be accepted ic. Malicious. Wounding, Rape, Abduction, Child Stealing, Kidnapping Arson & Sinking of Destroying Sea; a Vessel at I should be disposed to include all crimes of violence and all that I have that mentioned may be included under hrust . Suregrethy of the goon Desfalck with Sazla in pipe torber routed and say.
2026-05-28 18:38:25 · Baseline
View content

and to this the your is willing to accede

of alleged murder, manslaughter,

in

cases

pirncy burglary housebreaking and

rended

robbery

with violence, where the Accused has not

more than

6 months in Hong Kong

& where the depositions are taken before the British Consul who will certify that no compulsion appears to have been

uned it"

you will see that Section III of the draft Ordinance of 1889 contained a

provision

to the effect that depositions in China

3114/29]

should be taken as evidence [see on 314 pg] that this was approved of by Lord Knutsford in his Despatch parag: 5 ou 3114. The clause however met with the stingest the Unofficial hembers

opposition from of Council

les, et

see anuited

was omitted [see

newspaper Reports & also Sir

Vaux's Desfalch G des

on 17611.7

I consider that the prevent proposed safeguardi

though not entirely saliifactory

so b

au

497

sufficiently

warrant their being approved: we

not want to protect

justice,

do

1

to protect notorious criminals from

even Chinese justice; in fact I should

be inclined to go further than the gour

to add

the following crimes taken from

1989

the

Schedule of the Ordinance to the list of there;

auay

to which deponitions taken in China be accepted ic. Malicious. Wounding,

Rape, Abduction, Child Stealing, Kidnapping

Arson & Sinking of Destroying

Sea;

a

Vessel at

I should be disposed to include all

crimes of violence and all that I have that mentioned may be included under

hrust .

Suregrethy of the goon Desfalck with Sazla in pipe torber routed and say.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.